Points or cash back: which card pays more at Costco?
At Costco, what a card pays matters more than whether it’s called points or cash back: we count every reward in dollars at the value its issuer states. The CIBC Costco Mastercard pays 1% in the warehouse as a Costco gift certificate; points cards pay 0.5% to 1.5% there, and some can only be spent at their own stores. Checked November 18, 2026.
By the Cost Check team · Last reviewed November 18, 2026
What does each card pay at Costco, and in what?
| Card | In a Costco warehouse | Paid as |
|---|---|---|
| CIBC Costco Mastercard | 1% | Costco gift certificate each January |
| Triangle Mastercard | 0.5% | Canadian Tire Money, $1 for $1 at Canadian Tire, Sport Chek, Mark’s and the other Canadian Tire stores |
| BMO CashBack Mastercard | 0.5% | cash back, deposited to a BMO account or credited to the card (from $1) |
| Rogers Red World Elite Mastercard | 1.5% | cash back points, 1 point worth $0.01, redeemed from $10 |
| PC World Elite Mastercard | 1% | PC Optimum points, 10,000 points worth $10 in free groceries and more at Loblaw stores |
| Tangerine Money-Back Credit Card | 0.5% | cash back, paid every month |
| MBNA Rewards World Elite Mastercard | 0.8% | MBNA Rewards points, 120 points worth $1 as cash back (100 points per $1 toward travel) |
| Amazon.ca Rewards Mastercard | 1% | points loaded to your Amazon.ca account as an Amazon.ca gift card balance |
| Walmart Rewards World Mastercard | 1% | Walmart Reward Dollars, spent at Walmart in $5 steps |
| Rogers Red World Legend Mastercard | 1.5% | cash back |
| Brim World Elite Mastercard | 1% | cash back |
| Neo World Mastercard (Gas & Grocery) | 0.5% | cash back |
| MBNA Smart Cash Platinum Plus Mastercard | 0.5% | cash back |
| Scotia Momentum Mastercard | 0.5% | cash back |
| RBC Cash Back Mastercard | 0.5% | cash back |
| MBNA Rewards Platinum Plus Mastercard | 0.5% | cash back |
The rewards card terms come from each issuer’s own pages, read November 18, 2026: Canadian Tire Bank, BMO, BMO, Rogers Bank, Rogers Bank, Rogers Bank, President’s Choice Bank, President’s Choice Bank, Tangerine, Tangerine, MBNA, MBNA, MBNA, MBNA, Fairstone Bank of Canada, Fairstone Bank of Canada, Rogers Bank, Rogers Bank, Brim Financial, Brim Financial, Neo Financial, Neo Financial, MBNA, MBNA, Scotiabank, RBC, RBC, MBNA. Issuers can change these rewards card terms, and they decide who is approved; we earn nothing from any rewards card listed here.
More card guides for Costco shoppers
- The best cash back card for a Costco family
- No annual fee cards at Costco
- Restaurant cards, and the Costco card’s 3%
- Low interest cards that work at Costco
- No foreign transaction fee cards
- A travel card to pair with the Costco card
- Secured cards that work at Costco
- The best card to pair with the Costco Mastercard
- Business cards for Costco shoppers
- Student cards that work at Costco
- Costco credit cards compared

Card we recommend
$30 statement credit for new cardholders (first purchase and eStatements within 90 days), until December 20, 2026
- No annual fee
- 3% back on restaurants and Costco gas
- 2% back on Costco.ca, other gas and EV charging
- 1% back on everything else, including in Costco warehouses
- Paid once a year, in January, as a Costco warehouse gift certificate
- For Costco members; minimum annual income of $15,000
Terms from CIBC, checked November 18, 2026. How we pick cards
Questions
- Are points or cash back better for Costco?
- Whichever is worth more in dollars where you’ll spend it. Cash back you can spend anywhere is the safest; points and store dollars (Canadian Tire Money, PC Optimum, Walmart or Amazon credit) are worth their face value only at those stores.
- What is the Costco Mastercard’s cash back worth?
- Its face value at Costco: CIBC pays it once a year, in January, as a gift certificate to spend in any Costco warehouse in Canada.
- How do points convert to dollars?
- It depends on the card: MBNA Rewards points are 120 to $1 as cash back (100 to $1 toward travel), PC Optimum 10,000 to $10, Rogers points 1 cent each. The table uses each issuer’s cash value.
- Do points cards earn more at Costco?
- Not the ones we checked: at Costco they pay their everyday rate, 0.5% to 1.5%, against 1% to 3% on the CIBC Costco Mastercard.